I loved the book and I think the book demonstrates more of the sacrifice and danger that Skeeter, Aibileen and Minny went through. In writing the book, Skeeter sacrificed her friendships with Elizabeth and Hilly and became a social outcast. Also in writing the book, it opened her eyes about the mindset of her friends and how she could have ever been friends with them (especially Hilly). My heart especially broke for Skeeter when she lost Stuart for the second time. There was more to Skeeter and Stuart's relationship in the book than the movie so it was more heartbreaking to read. It also seems like a blessing in disguise because Skeeter realizes she wasn't meant to get married and settle down just yet. While there is not a sequel to this book, I imagine Skeeter went to New York and lived her dream of a writer/editor and probably found a man that had the same views as her.
One thing I liked about the movie better than the book was Skeeter's mom. There is redemption for her in the movie and I think I would have liked to seen it in the book as well. In the movie, her mom figures out Skeeter wrote the book and when Hilly drives over in a rage, her mom puts Hilly in her place. Then later she tells Skeeter how proud she is of her. I felt it provided that mother-daughter bond for Skeeter and her mom which used to be between Skeeter and Constantine.
I think the only redeeming quality Hilly has is that she loves her children. I don't remember any scenes with her showing affection to her kids and I wish it would have been included. I could understand Hilly having this misconception about the help having diseases and her coming up with the initiative to protect her children but Hilly is drunk on power. She just wants to ruin people who get in her way like Minny and Skeeter. I think its ironic though that if Hilly and the other ladies are concerned about diseases then why have the help at all? Oh yeah, that means they would have to do actual work.
Now that I've read it, I want to see the movie. I've been curious about all the changes that had been made. When the movie came out, we had a surge of people coming in for the book. The book in itself is pretty powerful. I'm so glad you chose this!
ReplyDeleteOk so hopefully I can re type this and actually remember what I put since my last comment didn't go through.
ReplyDeleteSo...I agree with everything you wrote about the comparisons between the book and the movie. I liked what they did with Skeeter's mom, I felt like she came to terms with what she did to Constantine. And she was able to make peace with Skeeter as well.
I felt like they didn't convey the danger that Skeeter and the maids faced when they started the book, it seemed more prevalent in the book. The same with Skeeter and the society ladies, in the movie seemed to stay friends longer.
I highly recommend the movie if you haven't seen it Allyssa, especially after finishing the book.